Readjust the drops of Bloody Branch

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

Description:
Right now there’s a custom change in Muh that allows BB to be dropped by Grote (0.92%) in Niff2 dungeon and Timbers (1.21%) in Mjolnir Underground Cave. My suggestion is to reduce the drop chance on those monsters and add additional drops on other tree monsters from high level maps, namely Depth Wood Goblin in Biosphere Depths, Bio Ancient Tree in Biosphere Abyss and Toxit in Encroached Geffenia. Actual numbers are left to the devs’ discretion but it should be proportional to the difficulty of the map (Geffenia>D2>D1>Mjol>Niff2).

Why is this a good idea?
The goal is to reduce the effectiveness of farming Niff2 and giving back some value in farming the others, while still maintaining the gimmick of trees dropping branches. At this point it’s no secret that farming Niff2 is very effective for raw zeny AND Bloody Branch, Mjolnir being slightly more effective for BB drop but way less interesting for zeny. The goal would be to make Niff2 still effective for zeny but open more interesting BB farming options for high gear players and give incentive to farm difficult maps.

What risks or downsides does it have?
The major downside is that for numbers to be right and not overflood the market with Mjolnir farming will probably have to become ineffective, unless Niff2 drop chance is nerfed to the point that it’s more interesting to go to Mjolnir even without the zeny gain.

Obviously if the numbers are too high it can create an overabundance of BB and MVP cards on the server, this one can be prevented by voluntarily undershooting the drop values at first and readjusting over time if the values are not meeting expectations.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: coffee (Flarum #668)

BB has definitely been adjusted several times in this game. It’s not possible to saturate an item with one of the highest recurrences in the market.
When you least expect it, some billionaire goes to the market and “grabs” all the BB to open them.

I think it’s perfect as it is, and it should stay that way.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

I never said the market was saturated with BB, that’s not a problem.

What I’m saying is niff2 is overcentralizing BB farm and that can be changed

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: SerenityMoon (Flarum #1455)

Even if BB drop rate is nerfed, we have 1x chars and shadowdeacon → BB conversion anyway. Even without nif2 zeny generation on this server is very easy. A Level 1 char can do gm events and seasonal events and get 500-600 muh coins every day, which, at the time of this comment is 180k each (90-100m a day). I got myself a full set of shadow gear with just muh coins at level 160 in like a week I cant even wear some of them because they require level 200 lol. Nowhere near nif2 level or ever seeing a BB.

In short, my opinion is that if you need a change of scenery, there are other maps to farm in. And there’s probably less people at the higher level areas anyway, Zeny being easy isnt going to change without drastic reworks.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

People please read the post, I’ve never said anything about the market being saturated with BB or with being bored of farming niff. Yes, alternatives exist.

I’m proposing a way to tune a nice gimmick of the server on order to give people more rewards for farming harder maps. This is not a nerf to BB drop, it’s a nerf to BB drop in niff2.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: SerenityMoon (Flarum #1455)

@telu

i DID mean to say specifically nerfing nif2 bb. Sorry for not hyper specifying that.

Edit: I actually did specifiy nif2. If my comment was read, you would see that I said “Even without nif2, zeny generation,” etc etc.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

No you didn’t, you said “Even if BB drop rate is nerfed, we have 1x chars and shadowdeacon → BB conversion anyway” which is true but not what I’m talking about.

The rest of your post you talk about zeny generation being easy even without niff2, which is also true but still not what the suggestion is about.

When I say “zeny generation is easy in Niff2” I mean that Niff2 already has a purpose in game as easy direct zeny generation (direct as in you sell to NPC, not players) and doesn’t really need to also be a source of BB. BB can be an indirect source of zeny generation but are also a way for end game players to get their missing MVP cards, which has no point in being at its most optimal in a mid game map. My suggestion aims to make BB farm more interesting when you are able to take on harder monsters.

I hope that clears the misunderstanding.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: Eneru (Flarum #1119)

-1 for the nerf. But +1 on expanding on other monsters, though i don’t think end-game content maps like D1, D2 and Geffenia should be elegible. Farming bloody branches should not be a side effect of farming the map, and we already farm those maps for mats.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: brozenwall (Flarum #614)

@Eneru TBH after the Zerocell most people move out of Geffenia/Valk so adding BB would make people go back and farm in party.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

@Eneru For D2 and geffenia I can agree with you but D1 has lost its purpose so it’s fine, isn’t it? If not, which maps would you suggest?

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: yurizeta (Flarum #846)

I think this is a good idea to make other maps also interesting for farming. I felt after zerocell, encroached valk and geffenia have become kinda pointless to run. You need a large party to make the party loot worth it, solo farming is not a good use of time. But the parties have also become scarce. This might make people come back and party up.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: coffee (Flarum #668)

@telu
Buddy, excuse me, but you’re advocating for your own interests. Suggesting this after reaching the endgame by farming thousands of Bloody Branches at the current rates on an easy/mid-game map sounds quite selfish. I don’t think adding other ways to obtain Bloody Branches on higher-difficulty maps is a bad idea, but suggesting a reduction in the current rates just because you’re no longer dedicating yourself to NIFF2 like you used to at the beginning, but instead to higher-difficulty maps, is quite contradictory and hard to accept.

Basically, most people build their characters on a 1x rate server specifically to farm recurring market items (Zelunium, Shadowdecon, Bloody Branch, etc.), so validating such a change wouldn’t make much sense.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: Akin (Flarum #861)

This should be 2 separate suggestion imo.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: Crosscy (Flarum #860)

can start with just introducing the branches to trees in D1, D2 (Maybe?) and Chapt1 Geffenia?

Follow the theme that trees are valuable; plus all these maps are meant to be farmed but isn’t done enough in muh VS kRO. Just nice they all have tree mobs

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

@coffee buddy you don’t know me I don’t farm niff2 because I care for my mental health, stop making an imaginary strawman in your head and getting mad at it.

I suggested the adjustment of rates because if you keep the actual ones + add even better rates in other maps then the server is going to get flooded with BBs and MVP cards, and I don’t think it’s a good idea. It’s not because of some petty reason like “oh I’m done farming this zone so nobody else should benefit from it”.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: EvilLumi (Flarum #372)

@telu The issue with your suggestion and your concern is: It already has. Upon the introduction of BBs to Niff2, the server has been slowly flooding with cards over the years. This isn’t some change which occurred a few months ago, it has been years, and players have already obtained what they wanted. (I hope)

The change you’re asking for, has already been discussed, and the conclusion at the time, to put simply, was: It wouldn’t be fair to new players.

At the time, and even now, people are joining and leaving, but fortunately, someone is joining. If they hear that BBs were easily accessible at some point in time, for YEARS, that will persuade them to leave, believing they could never catch up, and in most cases, that would be true.

Lots has happened since I’ve been gone, but I doubt that mindset has changed. Although your concern is valid, the damage you’re so afraid of has already been done in some way, and Muh (if I recall correctly, please forgive me if I’m wrong) has stated it was a regret to have put them there in the first place, but has worked to adjust other maps to be as profitable, if not MORE profitable to ease off the idea of farming BBs, which most I’m sure appreciated. It’s unfortunate, but pushing that change might hurt the server in ways keeping them won’t.

I personally like having things fair to everyone, before and after, and this is a drastic change to something that has been around for so long. I know the premise of the server ideology has changed, but I still believe both Muh and Ice want to keep things as fair as possible for everyone, otherwise, they would not be insisting on QoL changes, making things EASIER for the coming generation.

It was a bit of a read, so thank you for reading.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: coffee (Flarum #668)

@telu If you don’t farm, why are you suggesting reducing the drop rate on the map where beginners benefit from farming?
Just suggest adding the item to higher difficulty maps, without harming other players by reducing drop rates.
I’m not angry (you don’t know me either), you’re creating an archetype of me just for contesting your suggestion rationally. These are just ideas, there’s no emotion here. Thanks.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

@coffee you act like BB is the only thing that can be farmed in niff2 and it’s not already the most efficient raw zeny farm spot.

If we follow your suggestion of not changing the drop rates in niff and just adding higher and higher rates on harder maps the market is going to be flooded with BB and the price will drop so niff2 farmers will lose farm value all the same.

Lowering the absolute value of niff farming is one of the goals of this suggestion, as I personally think it’s sad that a mid level farming spot is so effective that it’s optimal over several other spots, and that’s partly because the higher drop rates of BB in mjolnir doesn’t compensate for the lost raw zeny.

If you think making niff less effective is bad then you’re not seeing the whole picture. If end game maps become more effective it means niff will become less crowded and mid game players will have less competition there. Everyone wins.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: telu (Flarum #782)

@EvilLumi I haven’t been there for that long but it’s often that a change in balance makes it unfair for people. Just last year there’s been a change to shape of fallen serpent that went from being dropped only in hard mode instance to every mob in a dungeon. The selling price of the item for divided by 100 in a week, is it fair for those who managed to farm them before the patch?

Same for the lof mats when the instance became party loot ready, the price is now 1/6th of what it was.

I think more than “is it fair for new/old players?” the question that should be asked is “what’s best for the server?”, like is the current amount of mvp cards close to what muh wants? Too high? Too low? Like I said I’ve only been on this server for a year or so, I don’t know if it was better when there were less BBs, or if more MVP cards would make playing there better. I just know that if you want to change things or keep it that way there are things that can be tuned.

Imported from legacy Flarum.
Original author: GM_Icecold (Flarum #3)

Always keep in mind that with the drop announce of mvp card it feels like “more cards” are available, but you don’t see how many bb’s or mvp kills in general are without drop.