In my opinion it depends on the change that were to be made.
I am strongly opposed to map wide loot sharing.
I am against New Party Loot System being removed from Happy Hour.
I am neither for nor against Giant Fly Wing (henceforth GFW) being disabled.
I am neither for nor against teleports being disabled during Happy Hour
I am for reducing notice period of Happy Hour maps to 30min - 1hour or removing notice altogether
I am neither for nor against increasing GFW cd to say 2s-5s
I understand the dislike of the Happy Hour meta where people just afk and first aid spam. This wasn’t exactly how the typical good Happy Hour was 7-8 months ago. (There would be a lot of solos in nif2/BioB/mjo_wst01). However, I do not think there is a clear or easy solution and do not think the suggestion as is would improve it. To an extent, that Pandora’s Box has been opened at this point, and there isnt much that can be done.
I also think that some of the other suggestions given are interesting in theory, but unrealistic to implement in my opinion. Some consideration should be put towards the ease of implementation, given the limitations of the game. That being said, I am not familiar with the back end of the game. I would prefer for muh/other back end staff to spend hours implementing such a system just for it to not work out. Currently, I believe ironing out existing issues with MuhGuard would be a better place to spend development time/resource rather than a new Happy Hour system that may or may not work out.
Firstly, I think GFW being disabled is an interesting option. I am not familiar with how the game system works for teleportation blocking, and if just blocking GFW is possible. I know that for Find Me 2(?) it blocks teleports as a whole, so blocking all teleports is a possible solution for Happy Hour. That could give some of the same feel of the HH where you have to walk. There are other concerns with this implementations, such as it being hard to keep the party together with Ninja’s ability to zoom around with infiltrate.
One potential change is to reduce the notice time of Happy Hour and give peopel 30min- 1 hour; or 5 min notice like it used to be. I do think that the extensive notice period has lead to Happy Hour being overcrowded and much more organized than it was in the past. Although, I think this is more of a bandage fix than anything else; and doesn’t change Happy Hour gameplay in itself. I also don’t enjoy how there are people looking for HH parties constantly from like 2-3 min after the Happy Hour is announced. If there is more time constraint for the organization of the said parties; this could alleviate some of the overcrowding concerns. This may be controversial as the Happy Hour map announcements are a very nice QoL. I do feel that this in part contributes to current culture/handling of Happy Hour.
Another potential change is to give GFW a longer cooldown of say 2-5 seconds. This would incentivize people to not afk as much, as there is a higher likelihood of death. The party would be more incentivized to clear the area around them to get maximum benefit. However, it does not prevent people from just being AFK and collecting their reward. This would make unlucky TPs more punishing and reduce the general loot from Happy Hour.
Let me play devils advocate here and voice my concerns about the changing Happy Hour from how it is currently
- Overcrowding concerns
Some maps do not have the density to support the number of players happy hour brings to them.
With 3-4 parties in mjolnir/nif2/bio B there are already a lot of times you tp into areas without mobs. Zerocell Lux basically only supports 1.5 parties. Enc Geffenia basically supports 1.5 parties with both parties suffering significant less loot that it would be better to go not durign happy hour.
With people scattered across the map without GFW there would be even less mobs to go around, and it will turn into what I have seen in KRO where people kill the 3-4 mobs in front of them and then try to find more. Personally, I do not think farming in that manner is particularly engaging either.
- Map wide happy hour would do nothing to combat leechers who do not want to participate.
With exp share being map wide, at UBH there were person(s) (whom I will not name), who were just afk on map not tping for 1-2 minutes at a time. There were even times where they did not tp for the basically the whole Mr. Kim duration after they tped to a quiet part of the map. The said person(s) would only tp when someone walked on their screen. Also even in the existing FTZ/Enc Geff HH there are often people who feign active contribution.
In my opinion, map wide happy hour is rife for abuse and the potential drama of people getting kicked for not contributing, and/or not being invited to party due to not having a meta class is not worth the headache of expanding New Party Loot System
- Potential concentration of meta even further with no GFW on Happy Hour maps
Currently Ninjas are already considered the meta farmer, without GFW enabled you would basically be encouraging other people to be playing ninja or inqui as no other classes can really keep up. Or if tp/leap is available SAs would be another potential meta class.
On FTZ HH, as is, some ninjas will be well over 3-4 screens ahead of SA/EM dpses who are barely stopping as is to clean up mobs. Although there are other parties in FTZ where EM/SA are basically the spearhead at the front of the party, those tend to be parties where the Ninjas aren’t as experienced/geared/actively contributing.
- Losing out on skill expression for pathfinders/lurer if New Party Loot system is map wide
There are niche/map specific strategies to maximize gains with how New Party Loot System functions as is such as: Titano’s Valk route (and existing minor optimizations from lurers), dual luring, DPS sweeping mobs, and general pathfinding skills (i.e. D2/Nox). Depending on map this can be a significant increase of drops. Find a few examples below.
As is ch1_gfn03 with dual lurers, solo party on map, and 4 dps would prob be targeting about 2.6k PB/Teal illusion stones per HH. A single lurer with DPS spread out in the typical “train style” would get about 2k PB/Teal illusion stones per HH.
For Zerocell Nox, a solid party would be looking at 4-5k boxes/Chaotic Runes with no HE. With proper routing, being the solo party on the map you can get ~6-7k on the map with no HE.
My memory is a bit fuzzy on Valk parties, but an experienced Valk party with ninja sweeping outer lane could get 18k Moving Black Material (bench mark for Valk runs). An experienced Valk party would be closer to 13-15k Moving Black if they had experienced lurers/dps that would fan out to clear all the mobs. My last Valk run during Happy Hour soon after Zerocell release, had about 12k Moving black primarily due to people not having the map knowledge/sweeping mobs as efficiently.
As someone who actually enjoys playing the pathfinder/lurer role, I would not appreciate the role being basically obselete. Field farming path efficiency is also a skill that would no longer be tested with map wide New Party Loot System. I do not think the tedium of GFW Happy Hour maps is worth sacrificing how enjoyable some of the other non-GFW Happy Hour maps are.
- Potential economic impact of Map Wide Happy Hour
I personally think that the existing implementation of Happy Hour is already pretty unhealthy for the economy.
I think map wide New Party Loot System would actually increase drops for people, rather than decrease drops especially in scenarios such as Zerocell/Enc Geff given that typically only a few dps actually do most of the killing in that kind of content.
In places liek Bio B/Nif2 given the demand/density/ number of potential players on the map, the effect is uncertain if it would be a straight up buff. But in my opinion it would be a buff to Happy Hour on those maps.